The Meat Industry

Bianca Pasello
Meats are consumed regularly by the majority of the worlds population, but the vast environmental consequences of meat consumption often go unrecognized. Not only are animals mistreated at times, but raising them and manufacturing their meat causes resource consumption. We also need to spend extra money on maintaining the animals at optimal conditions so that higher quality meats are achieved. Because of all these reasons, Joseph Poore, from the University of Oxford, claims that a “vegan diet is probably the single biggest way to reduce your impact on planet Earth, not just greenhouse gases, but global acidification, eutrophication, land use and water use.”

It is obvious, though, that his suggestion is not a completely realistic solution, but what if there was a way around all these issues? Thanks to modern technology, there is a way! Scientists have been able to successfully creat lab grown meat. They extract a few cells of a cows muscle tissue and are able to grow them to a larger size on a petri dish until it is a large enough piece to be cooked. At first, many may feel disgusted by this idea, but it has a great number of advantages. There are personal health benefits that can be achieved. These lab made meats do not come from a live animal, so they will be absent of any diseases such as E. Coli, no antibiotics or growth hormones would be used in the process of creating them, and they are technically inline with vegan diet requirements so they can provide vegans with a sufficient source of protein.

This may seem like a far fetched idea that needs more time to develope, but these lab grown meats are already available! A company named Memphis Meats is already promoting and selling this product. While it is still a bit pricy, as the product grows in popularity, and can be mass produced, the prices will lower substantially. According to those who have already tried the meat, it is nearly equivalent to the real thing, it’s just a little dry, but adjustments are being made to make the two indistinguishable. This solution has the potential to greatly reduce humanities ecological footprint. Is it possible that enough people will accept this new form of meat to make a difference? Would vegans/vegetarians be comfortable consuming this product even though no animals are harmed or killed in the process? How could this product be made more realistic and affordable?

www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/may/31/avoiding-meat-and-dairy-is-single-biggest-way-to-reduce-your-impact-on-earth.
The book Unnaturally Delicious




Comments

Anonymous said…
I don’t believe a ton of people will be able to consume this new product to make a significant difference. I personally would not eat this product because I like meat too much. I think people will not switch from normal beef to this new form of meat. There could be a fear of meat made in a lab which would make people hesitate to try this new food. Vegans and vegetarians (some of them not all) don’t eat meat due to the fact that it hurts the animals in the process or just that. The fact that any part of animal is used in the process could be a problem for some people. The price could be expensive which would also drive people away from the new form of meat. With all of these factors combing together, I don’t see this alternative being consumed very much to have a significant impact.
Anonymous said…
I feel like if this is more expensive than normal meat, which is already pretty expensive, it will not catch on. I could however, catch on with vegans because they love their fake substitutes like fake cheeses. We also do not know the downsides of this fake meat and it could be harmful. There are better ways to get protein than eating fake meat. It is ok to eat meat if it isn’t absolutely all the time. Things like beans and soy are better to be protein subsitutes than a lab-made meat. By definition, meat is animal, not a creation of a lab. I agree that it is not sustainable the way we are consuming meat, but I do not think that this is the solution.
Anonymous said…
Becoming vegan might seem like a very drastic life change, but it might not be as hard as one might think. Living a vegan lifestyle doesn’t have to mean being completely vegan, but choosing vegan option and vegan tendencies over meat and dairy most of the time. Living this way will significantly lessen greenhouse gases and climate change. If people are opposed to vegan lifestyles, lab grown meat seems to be a quickly growing alternative. Tests show that some people cant even taste a difference in lab grown meat versus real meat. These lifestyles will help the entire global population and the future populations.
Anonymous said…
I’m all for saving the world and reducing my impact on the environment. However I could just never go vegan. I could definitely give artificial meat a try, but I seriously worry about the possible health risks of it. Furthermore if you consider the food chain, and bear with me here, wouldn’t humans technically be considered the primary consumers of things like cows and chickens? If we eliminate ourselves as the primary consumer then what happens to the populations of those animals? I would assume that the population would grow and then it would be up to us to restore balance, by having to do population control. But if nobody eats meat, then the animals who will lose their lives will go to waste. Humans are an essential part of the food chain, like all other living things. If we change our habits drastically then I’m sure there will be unforseen repercussions later down the road.
Anonymous said…
Personally speaking I highly doubt I will eat this at all because I need that juicy and natural meats only. Although it’s healthier imagine eating a juicy fattening burger, it negates the whole premise of being healthier. Now another issue I have with it is that it’s created in a lab. Not only is it more expensive because it’s genetically modified, but imagine seeing the process at which they make a Petri dish of cow muscle to “new meat.” Being the devil’s advocate also, humans really have made poultry and other meats industries into a factory system to ensure that every meat is the same and for the standards of human needs. But, then again it brings up another issue of driving away the need for these factories is people who don’t want genetically modified meats. Which brings back the lab meats, what are they then? This could drive away the clean eating people who won’t even go near anything with antibiotics or other artificial circumstances to make a uniform meat. So then who will eat these new meats?
Anonymous said…
I don't think that there is a large enough market for this alternative meat product to have a major effect. I think vegans will largely stay away from a product like this given that they already were willing to give up meat, as well as the fact that the product still uses part of an animal. Non vegans won't need this substitute because they can just eat normal meat. Also, i think people will be naturally skeptical about a food product grown in a lab. Having the product grown 100% in a lab just seems very unnatural to me and I assume others. I think people should instead focus most on having and maintaining a balanced diet to decrease their ecological footprint. Eating a ton of meat is definitely not good for a persons health, as well as the environment. Maintaining a balanced diet with a limited dependence on meat will be the best way to drive down ones ecological footprint without sacrificing eating meat completely.
Anonymous said…
I probably wouldn’t be open at first to trying the lab made meat products, but if it does become popular then I’d consider it. It would take a long time for it to become a product at every household. Artificial meat would become a threat to the actual meat industry as well. Making the artificial meat also requires electricity, so the use of energy might actually increase. The method to make artificial meat isn’t too bad and if people are disgusted at first then they should really also get some insight on traditional methods. The animal slaughter farm to me is worse than extracting some tissue.
Anonymous said…
Veganism, although it is the most environmentally sustainable option, it is not practical. Speaking from personal experience, i highly doubt i would ever go vegan just because meat is my favorite food and one of my only protein sources. However, i would be extremely open to lab made meat products. I think its such a cool and good idea. It is practical and very efficient. The only problem is that is still very expensive. I think and hope that in a couple of years meat labs popularize and are one of the main sources in our society for protein rather than normal beef.
Anonymous said…
While this idea is truly interesting, I personally do not think I could bring myself to invest in this product. Eating meat as well as not eating meat is a cultural and sometimes religious relation. This product also seems very expensive, even more so than the already expensive meat. Due to these reasons, I do not think this idea is practical.
Anonymous said…
I didn’t even know that this food source was an option. I always was food as either straight from plants or animals, but I never considered that they could be grown in a lab. I think many people would be open to this idea because it promotes a better diet, less diseases, and is more environmentally friendly. If we could show this innovation to others, then a greater change can be produced. However, I do believe that vegetarians and vegans may not be comfortable eating this. The product comes from animals still, and many people become vegetarian or vegan for the sole purpose of not eating animals. I think if we showed them that the animals are not harmed in the process and that it is very sustainable, then they would try it. Through mass production (if possible), then the price will definitely decrease significantly. Also, selling it as a standard will also decrease the price.
Anonymous said…
This sounds like an interesting idea and a possible way to reduce our ecological footprints. However, I don’t think a lot people will accept this new form of meat, especially those who are vegan/vegetarian. Even though this doesn’t harm the animals and it does save the environment, vegans/vegetarians would not be comfortable eating this because they still do come from the animal. Personally, I would think that if people heard that the food they were eating came from cells of cow muscle tissues, they wouldn’t eat it. It doesn’t sound very appealing and appetizing. The price for this meat right now is a bit pricy but I think if the price was lower, people would be willing to give it a try.
Anonymous said…
This sounds like a very imteresting idea and I personally would be up to trying it. However, I don’t think it’s going to become a staple in anyone’s diet anytime soon. People eat for convenience, whatever’s cheap and whatever tastes good is what most people are drawn to. I think this would be a great idea to help the environment because of the damage that the meat industry causes, but people arent thinking of the environment when they’re eating. I’m not sure vegans would like this because it’s still an animal product, but vegetarians who don’t eat meat due to harm to the animals would most likely be willing to try it. It’d be great if this could work, but I don’t think it’s practical because too many people would be skeptical of lab grown meat and its inconvenience.
Anonymous said…
So, I'm a huge meat fan and to be honest, I'll eat any meat substitute if it tastes like meat and not 3D printed plastic strands. Now I'm one for trying things, but most people wont stick to this lab meat unless it was affordable and was made a commonality in places such as groceries and restaurants. For instance, the middle class in America is only earning an average of $80,000 a year. Low income to poverty make about $40,000 or less a year. Both classes make the majority of the population here, which is why lab meats will not be picked up anytime soon by the average American person. I sorrow for the cruel treatment of animals, however the meat industry is multiplying these animals at a faster rate to keep meat prices low and affordable to a good portion of the population; their target marketing clients are in he lower and middle class. Rich upper class people live lavish lives and prefer to dabble in expensive meats like lamb, lobster, and meats that are just prepared professionally with high grade meats. Companies don't need to entice the rich man when they have a wider audience who buy more consistently and buy the same thing more frequently. Lab meats aren't the cheap future of tomorrow, but they might just be in the future.
Anonymous said…
This seems like a good idea in theory, but may not be effective in the long run because of the easy access to regular meat and our resistance to trying new things. This new meat source would have to made affordable and common so that we would feel more inclined to eat it. However, the meat industry today is very popular and necessary for people to buy cheap meat, causing many people to turn away from this new idea. Many people may be closed off to this idea even if it isn’t harming animals because of the representation of this growing in a lab. Personally, I would not try this because it sounds uncomfortable to eat as it is not an actual food source even though I am vegetarian. I think this idea might be a little too far-fetched, but if a few people try it and confirm it is a good source of food, it may gain popularity in the coming years.
Anonymous said…
I definitely feel that not enough people will embrace the new meat in order for us to make a significant environmental impact as a society. It is extremely hard to change people’s mindsets about food, since they have been accustomed to eating a certain way for generations, and it can also be influenced by politics and a variety of other factors. Although it might taste similar, there are bound to be people who don’t like the idea of eating meat made in a scientific laboratory, even though scientifically it is the same thing. Also, due to religious reasons, I don’t eat beef or pork, so I wouldn’t be able to even try it and give an honest opinion. Even if I did, though, I would find it weird eating something that doesn’t occur naturally.
Anonymous said…
This whole idea sounds extremely interesting for me. Although I feel like this would be a great idea to help reduce the overall environmental overconsumption as well as pollution, I think it would be very difficult for this to work out. This is something that would take a significant amount of time. Because of people’s perceptions on food, it is very hard to change people’s perspectives and opinions on the aritifically created meats as many believe that it is unhealthy. However like the article said, there are health benefits of being absents of any diseases. I believe that we must inform the public and show them how it is fine to consume this new lab-grown meats.
Anonymous said…
This is a very crazy idea to me. Although it should be as healthy and safe, if not better, I don't know if I would want to eat it. It just creeps me out a little bit. And the fact that is is vegan yet meat is the weirdest paradox ever. However, if the science behind this is developed and advanced, this could be a solution to several problems facing the world right now: livestock, atmosphere, etc. Right now, this is an unrealistic change, but maybe in a few years it will be sold in grocery stores.
Anonymous said…
Upon hearing the words “lab grown meat” my initial take is how unappetizing that sounds. However, after reading about the potential benefits and upside of eating lab-grown meat, the meal doesn’t seem so unnatural. In fact, now I am curious as to how this compares to real meat and would like to taste-test the two and find any differences. Hopefully as research continues to be invested in this process, prices will continue to lower and more people will take into consideration the viability of lab-grown meat and how it can reduce the world’s pollution significantly. For now, I think it is best to continue to let research do it’s work until the price lowers, and then once the price is at a low enough point to where the average person can afford eating it, then education should be invested in so that viability of the meat can be spread. Thus with more affordable prices, more people will be willing to try the meat out.
Anonymous said…
I don't think vegetarians would eat this because they don't eat any types of meat. They specifically don't eat meat because they don't like the feeling of eating animals. And like you said, the price is more expensive than normal, so there would be no way they would consider this transition. Other than vegetarians, the people who do eat meat will also not consider this transition because of the cost. Meat is already expensive as it is for most people and this transition wouldn't be in their best interest.
Amogh Gokhale said…
I think that even though this lab grown meat may be safer, no one will buy it. If I see two identical pieces of meat, and one is more expensive, I am going to buy the cheaper one. I think that we can definitely work on stopping animal cruelty and mistreatment, but there is a little chance that people would be willing to switch to lab grown meat, as just saying the words GMO strikes fear into the hearts of many, so lab grown meat wont catch on.
Anonymous said…
I believe that this idea has the potential to be very helpful to the world. Undoubtedly, there will be a lot of resistance from individuals that have a high value for meat in their lives (even I am a little skeptical). However, if this could become a reality, this might be the fastest way to save our planet. Additionally, those who choose to be vegiterian or vegan due to the cruelty against animals would likely be abroad with this concept. However, the majority of vegiterians/vegans I know do it for their health. The impact of meat on ones body has been studied in depth recently by accredible scientists. Many individuals consume more meat than necessary in their diets, resulting in health problems in the future. Due to this being the reason than many people are vegiterian, it is unlikely that they will switch to this concept. In order for this to be successful, it needs to be mass produced and made available to the average American (rather than high paying buyers).
Anonymous said…
I feel like it will very difficult for this meat substitute to catch on. Since it's expensive, people will be reluctant to try it, and in order for it to get cheaper, more people will need to purchase it. In addition, people may already be reluctant to try meat grown in a lab, rather than meat obtained from animals. While it sounds like a great substitute, people may not like the idea of food grown in a lab, even if it is healthier and less taxing on the environment. However, if we give it enough time, I'm sure that this can be a realistic substitute for meat. It will just take a while for people to accept it. I do not believe that vegetarians would consume meat, regardless of if it was grown in a lab or not.
Anonymous said…
I don't believe people would switch to this lab grown meat substitute. Vegans would not eat this lab grown meat because they do not eat any meat at all. This is a remarkable idea developed by science but I just don't see how it could work, especially since it is more expensive than other meats. A couple more decades and maybe this will become more readily available and viable, we just need to teach people.
Anonymous said…
I really dont think that the masses would jump for this lab made meat. People dont trust gmos nor gluten. The second they hear that this is completely lab grown, they would immediately began to speculate that iys not good for people to eat weigher or not that is true. The masses would not take the time to educate themselves and would assume it is going to cause bodily harm to those who do consider to eat the “meat”. I also highly doubt that vegan/vegetarians would eat this meat. Many are not only eating this way because of their love of animals but out of the health benefits. I myself would be weiry to eating the lab grown meat.
Anonymous said…
I don’t think that this idea would be accepted immediately as there are many discussions of lab made substances. I think it is usually hard for people to accept the new when they know that the old is safe. As there is many debates for genetically modified organisms that also help for mass food produce there is a stigma that rises because of it. I personally feel like this is specifically targeted for the meat eaters, not the vegetarians. Meat in general is more expensive than vegetables and when it is more costly than normal meat I think it will discourage people to buy it.
Anonymous said…
I do believe that the meat industry harms the environment as it has been so heavily industrialized. However, I’m not sure if lab made meat would be a plausible option for most people. It’s a bit hard to get past the “lab made” label for some people, and the higher price point likely does not help. I think that meat has been made an everyday food in America, whereas most other countries consider it a luxury, so the effects of the meat industries in other countries are not as severe. Vegan and vegetarian diets are not the only alternative; anyone can cut back on meat consumption and still make a difference.
Anonymous said…
I would definitely eat the heck out of this meat. I'm not sure how this meat can be mass produced more cheaply than farm animals, though. But, assuming that it can, then the benefits to the environment are numerous. Less land is needed for raising animals, less methane is produced, less crop is needed for feed. The only rational reason to prefer "real" meat is because it's cheaper, but that'll end once the costs of lab grown meat has decreased. Of course, there will be people who claim this lab meat isn't natural and is therefore not good.
Anonymous said…
In my opinion, as the human population continues to rise, we will have no choice but to find alternative ways to mass produce foods even if it is non traditional. This means that although many people will be suspicious and wary of trying lab food, we must do our best to prove the non lethal effects of lab food and how it can greatly benefit the population by providing more sustenance. If we can achieve this, we will be able to sustain a growing population and providing the necessary amounts of protein.
Anonymous said…
While this type of meat would be a great idea, i think it would be extremely hard to get a mass population of people to convert to this new type of meat. One of the many flaws of humans is trying new things that are out of the norm, even if the new thing is so much better for not only them, but also for the world around them. The idea of this new meat would revolutionize the meat industry as a whole, I just don't think it will take off.

Popular posts from this blog

What's the deal with airline food?

What We Can Recycle

Land Pollution Is Not The Solution